Fisheaters.com

Over at Catholic Answers, I have had another thread locked while I was in the middle of composing a reply. In this case, the discussion was whether Fisheaters.com is a trustworthy site, and in particular whether they had put up some faked screenshots here, in order to discredit EWTN. I have linked to the Fisheaters website several times in this blog.

Here is what I wanted to post:

Quote:

Originally Posted by LilyM Quote: Originally Posted by MikeDunphy Do you think that Fisheaters may have faked the screenshots? It's not impossible - certainly anti-Catholics have faked all sorts of things over the centuries!

I don't know whether it helps any, but three people (VoxClamantis, AdoramusTeChriste, Mark) in a Fisheater's discussion forum here say they saw the original answer with their own eyes. Also, Hillary from the Devout Life blog commented on the answer here, when it first came out. I think Ian's comment on a follow-up post on the same blog here sounds authentic, although of course that is a judgment call.