Confessional Scholarship

From "the lidless eye" (kind of a creepy name - sounds like an homage to Sauron):

In my own experience, Davies' work is rather misleading. He makes a lot of assumptions that are not warranted with the evidence he supplies. Further still, he is too wedded to confessional scholarship and does not seem to be able to approach the subject of the liturgy with any sense of objective fairness.

Is the lidless eye accusing Mr. Davies of taking an excessively Catholic view of things? An odd accusation for one Catholic to hurl at another.